Special counsel Jack Smith argues Judge Tanya Chutkan shouldn't recuse herself in Trump case

18:05 15.09.2023

In a dramatic turn of events, Special Counsel Jack Smith has requested that former President Donald Trump be limited in his public statements regarding the case against him for alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election. Smith accuses Trump of making "inflammatory public statements" with the intention of influencing potential jurors and intimidating witnesses. This request comes after a series of posts made by Trump on his Truth Social platform since his indictment in August.

In a 24-page filing submitted on Friday, Smith and his team of prosecutors presented a list of Trump's posts on Truth Social, stating that the former president had been spreading disparaging and inflammatory content on a near-daily basis. They argue that Trump is aware of his ability to incite threats and harassment against his targets through his posts. To counteract this, the government lawyers have asked Judge Tanya Chutkan to impose a "narrowly tailored" order that would prevent Trump from making extrajudicial statements that could materially prejudice the case.

The prosecutors assert that Trump's repeated claims of not receiving a fair trial from the court or a jury of his peers in the District of Columbia are likely to undermine confidence in the justice system and influence the jury pool. They argue that his misleading statements regarding the Special Counsel's Office and its investigation serve the same purpose. Additionally, they accuse Trump of targeting specific witnesses in an attempt to influence public opinion before the trial even begins.

Donald Trump was indicted by a federal grand jury on four charges related to his alleged attempts to reverse the 2020 election results. He has pleaded not guilty to these charges. The motion filed by Special Counsel Jack Smith seeks to limit Trump's public statements to prevent further damage to the justice system and potential interference with the ongoing trial.

In response to Trump's request for Judge Tanya Chutkan to recuse herself from the case, Special Counsel Jack Smith has filed a forceful motion arguing that there is no valid basis for her disqualification. Smith's 20-page filing, submitted just an hour before the deadline set by Chutkan, states that Trump has not provided sufficient evidence of biased claims made by the judge.

Smith's motion emphasizes that for a recusal claim to be successful, Trump must show that Chutkan displayed deep-seated animosity towards him, which he has failed to do. According to Smith, Trump's repeated assertions that the judge's comments suggest bias or prejudice are insufficient to meet the burden of proof. The Special Counsel firmly states that Trump cannot point to any statements expressing actual bias from Chutkan.

Trump's legal team argued in a filing on Monday that Chutkan should recuse herself due to previous statements she made while sentencing defendants involved in the Capitol riot. They allege that Chutkan had suggested President Trump should be prosecuted and imprisoned, and that such statements are inherently disqualifying. They pointed to comments made by the judge, including one in which she stated that the violent attempt to overthrow the government came from "blind loyalty to one person who, by the way, remains free to this day."

Ultimately, the decision to recuse herself lies with Judge Tanya Chutkan. If she chooses to recuse, a new judge would be assigned to the case. However, Trump's attorneys could appeal to an appeals court to require her recusal, although such efforts are often unsuccessful. Trump will have the opportunity to respond to Smith's counterarguments, with his deadline set for next week. The case continues to unfold, with both sides presenting their arguments before the court.

/ Friday, September 15, 2023, 6:05 PM /

themes:  Donald Trump  Washington

All rights to the materials belong to the sources indicated under the heading of each news and their authors.